Dispersing to the Periphery

One thousand new jobs in a city of 12 million may not be too exciting. One thousand jobs in a city of half a million is something to write home about. In the Philippines' Visayas region, Iloilo is fast becoming a favored destination. It's no surprise that a city with six universities and thousands of fresh graduates a year would become a viable location for outsourcing companies. Other wannabee cities looking to boost development need remember that besides the available labor pool, another ingredient is necessary -- reliable telecommunication links to the rest of the world -- before they prepare the powerpoint presentations to lure companies to their neck of the woods.

Transcom, touted to be Europe's largest business process outsourcing (BPO) firm, will open a call center in Iloilo in 2009, and will hire from 1,000 to 2,000 employees.

The investment is expected to cement the city's place among the top new wave international BPO sites.

Iloilo City Mayor Jerry Treñas said Transcom has set the hiring of around 1,060 employees in October. It is planning to double its work force after it starts its operations, according to Treñas.

Transcom has 75 sites in 29 countries worldwide and has expertise in various industries including telecommunications, the financial industry, travel and leisure, utilities and retail/consumer goods. It has around 20,000 employees serving over 120 major clients in more than 30 languages.

The investment has also affirmed the city as among the top new BPO investment sites in the world.

The city already hosts nine BPOs with more than 4,000 workers. These include Teletech, ePLDT Ventus, Callbox Customer Contact Center, Global Mega Communications Inc., Techno Call Corp., Interactive Voice Call Center, Medlink Trans Services, Eversun Software Philippines Corp., and Savant Technologies.

Getting to 20% With Ayala

As eTelecare's (ETEL) shares tumbled, the Philippines' oldest conglomerate and owner of the country's biggest bank and biggest real-estate company made good on its intentions to boost its stake.

According to information reported by Ayala Corp. to US regulators, the conglomerate now owns 6.39 million ETEL shares, or 22.22% of the BPO. Ayala first bought into ETEL in June 2006, when press reports said it paid about 800 million pesos for 11% of the company, using LiveIt Solutions Inc. as its investment vehicle.

The shares may have just been transferred from one Ayala pocket to another. Check out Ayala Corp.'s US SEC filing. There are more layers in this than a wedding cake: Ayala wholly owns Azalea International Venture Partners Ltd., which wholly owns LiveIt Investments Ltd., which in turn wholly owns Newbridge International Investment Ltd. Newbridge, after all, was an original investor in eTelecare. In an early November filing, Ayala said additional investments in eTelecare were for "investment purposes."

Ayala Corporation currently intends, depending on market and other conditions, and in its sole discretion, to consider acquiring additional Shares of the Issuer and thereby increase its total beneficial ownership interest to 20% of total outstanding Shares on a fully diluted basis (or approximately 22% of the Issuer’s total current outstanding Shares on an undiluted basis), in order, among other things, to allow Ayala Corporation to account for its Shares under the equity method of accounting.

Even then, it's usually a good sign when a major shareholder puts it on record that it is the shareholder on record, instead of burying it in an offshore vehicle domiciled in some balmy tax haven. After all, Ayala will not want to get above the 20% threshold if it's expecting poor performance from ETEL going forward.

The First Gram is Always Free

There's a study out by Compact Management Consulting on how IT and BPO outsourcers deliver cost savings in the first year, and then ratchet up their prices in successive years, making them the costlier option for a company than if it kept the service in-house.

The research, based on an analysis of 240 deals worth more than £20m, found that outsourcing providers were pricing contracts to produce savings of up 18% compared with in-house costs in the first year. But costs then began to escalate, reaching 36% above comparable top quartile internal operations by year three. . . .

Simon Scarrott, head of business development and marketing at Compass, said: “With those figures, it is easy to see why the claim that all outsourcing will save money is a myth. There can be sound strategic reasons for outsourcing but saving money over the long term is not one of them.”

He added: “Outsourcing providers are not that different from an in-house operation. Indeed, they often use the same people as the in-house operation after the deal is signed and outsourcers cannot perform alchemy on a business process and turn an operation into gold.”

Hold on. There are significant savings involved if the business model is to arbitrage the labor costs between an expensive developed country's workers and the cheaper rates available in a developing country. So even if you are still using the same number of IT programmers, clerks, project managers, and customer representatives, there's no doubt the correct outsourcer can do it, cheaper.

Then again, even if you, the chief information officer of a fast-growing company, take the Compass study as gospel truth, you can always choose what Aviva has done -- get an outsourcer to build it for you so you can enjoy the first and second-year savings, and then take over the facility.

The previous month, Aviva transferred 1,600 employees in Bangalore from an outsourcing vendor, 24/7 Customer, to Aviva Global Services. It was the first move of its kind and size in the Indian business processing outsourcing industry, NASSCOM said.

When a vendor creates a call center for a company, runs it for a certain period of time, then hands the operation over to the company, it's called the build-operate-transfer (BOT) model. Typically, a company moving operations to India would build the operation from scratch, or subcontract the operation to an outsourcing vendor, or some combination of the two.

The BOT approach lets a company get going in India faster, Aviva executives said at the ceremony in Mumbai. That helps Aviva, and its Norwich Union insurance subsidiary, adapt to change, [Executive Director Patrick] Snowball said when he accepted the award.

"Our excellent operations in India are critical for us to ensure we maintain a competitive advantage," he said. Aviva has worked with three vendors under the BOT model: EXL, WNS and 24/7 Customer. Over the course of the year, 5,000 employees will be transferred from those vendors to Aviva's own offshore division. The Bangalore facility was just the first to be transferred. Later this year, the company will transfer facilities in Sri Lanka to its control, and in Pune.

Media KPO

Who will be the first in the Philippines to provide outsourcing for America's television industry? According to televisionpoint.com, which tracks the Indian TV industry, Infosys is about to tie up with India's TV18 group to do production work and provide the technology backbone to make it easier to get the digital content we all crave.

The Philippine broadcast industry has the same untapped capabilities -- it's a matter of marrying it with someone who will have enough credibility among TV titans in the U.S. so that those services will be bought.

Sources said the TV18 group was in advanced talks with Infosys BPO and was in the process of finalising the management team that would head this venture. The size of the deal is unavailable, but according to company sources, the deal will involve use of the TV18 brand name and the technology and delivery capabilities of Infosys BPO. This will include rolling out online initiatives and creating technology platforms for high-definition content, digital content and projects that involve editing media-related content.

According to infotech analysts, Infosys BPO is increasingly focusing on getting more knowledge process outsourcing work. According to PricewaterhouseCoopers, the global media-entertainment industry is estimated at $1.3 trillion (India's GDP in the region of $800 billion) is and is expected to grow to $1,7 trillion by the end of 2009. Infosys is India's second largest infotech software services exporter. TV18, with interests in television and Internet business, runs four television channels including news and entertainment and about a dozen Internet portals spanning technology to travel.